| QUOTE (Disgustedorite @ Apr 15 2023, 09:00 AM) |
| While microbe hybrids are allowed by the letter of the rule, lots of things that would be rejected are. Can you answer how they hybridized? If not, I'm tempted to insta-reject. |

| QUOTE (colddigger @ Apr 13 2023, 03:09 PM) |
| Can .. .. can you elaborate on how it is better at storing water in it's cells? For example, a better cuticle in some way, a thicker epidermis, or a sealing slime coat that takes the brunt of the environment |
| QUOTE (colddigger @ Apr 13 2023, 12:18 AM) |
| can you elaborate on why it doesnt need to go back to the water |

| QUOTE (colddigger @ Apr 10 2023, 11:35 PM) |
| What a fun flora, always happy to see unique purple plants. |



| QUOTE (Coolsteph @ Apr 8 2023, 10:22 AM) |
| Just a quick check: As Disgustedorite said, blackflora trees are wind-pollinated, with no pollinators*. However, if you really want to preserve that detail, you could co-evolve this with a species based on beetles which pollinate cycads, which are similarly wind-pollinated: "[Cycads] are wind pollinated, a strategy which requires immense amounts of airborne pollen. A few may have been pollinated by beetles attracted to the edible pollen grains. This may be the humble beginnings of the complex animal pollination developed by flowering plants." http://www2.tulane.edu/~bfleury/diversity/...e/gymangio.html *The Maulwart is one example of a blackflora with pollinators, but that's on Fermi and it isn't a tree. There are no "Snowflake Obsiditree". You meant "Snowflake Obsidoaks". It's important to know they have eyes on their rears, but those aren't visible in this image, nor referred to in the description. |
.png)

| QUOTE (Coolsteph @ Apr 6 2023, 08:53 AM) |
| Image: There are some stray lines on the cheek, around the throat, between the two biggest spikes, and possibly around the eyes and the spikes. Admittedly, those lines might actually indicate light-green natural markings, and it might have conspicuous white parts on the ends of its tail spikes. I’m not sure why it would have conspicuous white parts on the end of its tail spikes, but those parts are so small they would surely have little effect on survival or plausibility, and so technically don’t need to be corrected. Similarly, some of the spikes on its back aren’t fully filled: the ones on its shoulders are particularly glaring. These issues aren’t bad enough to stall approval, but since it would be a quick fix, I recommend correcting it anyway. Template: Oofle Archipelago Polar Beaches, plural? Description: More Important Feedback How does it spread its “favorite roots”? Since the spore-bearing structures are far from the roots for most of them, it’s hard to imagine it would store spores from its favored flora in its mouth while eating roots. I’m not sure how many, if any, of its favored flora can grow back from root fragments. “As a result of dealing with the colder temperatures, it has become a mesotherm”. Not every animal that experiences cold temperatures in its native habitat becomes a mesotherm. Some frogs in Canada endure winter through being frozen alive, for example. This therefore should be re-phrased. It would also help to draw inspiration from real mesotherms to explain this change. It’s so large gigantothermy could apply, although it might lose heat through its spikes. A rete mirabile might also keep its body temperature elevated, and a layer of blubber or fat would reduce the rate of heat loss to the environment, whatever its internal heat generation was like. Plausibility/Encouraged Elaboration It’s a bit odd it should be aquatic and yet not feed on anything underwater or at the water’s edge. The spikes would also create a lot of drag, slowing it down in the water. (Admittedly, the spike-like finlets on a tuna’s tail do have a hydrodynamic function.) I suppose, though, if it’s a slow-moving underwater creature like a manatee that spends most of its time low in the water column, being heavy and unaerodynamic wouldn’t matter. With its short legs, it would surely not be fast on land. It is well-armored and has a thagomizer, though. Its survival odds on land might depend on how its young live. Does the mother abandon them shortly after they are born? If they are aquatic, do the females no longer seal themselves in their burrows with their eggs? If the young are abandoned shortly after they are born, their short legs combined with smaller body sizes might make them easy prey for any predators that can handle their spikes and thagomizers (e.g., shrogs; I didn’t specifically check all the habitats, but shrugs are so widespread they’re probably found in some of them). The most obvious workaround for this is sea turtle-style reproduction. |
.png)
| QUOTE (colddigger @ Apr 5 2023, 03:28 PM) |
| I really like this setup, is the 1 m height including the bubbles on stalks? |
| QUOTE (Disgustedorite @ Apr 4 2023, 06:19 PM) |
| 5 pounds is very light for something with a 5 meter wingspan. This creature is much heavier in proportion. |
| QUOTE (Disgustedorite @ Apr 4 2023, 06:29 PM) |
| How do they disperse? What happens if a nimbus colony dies? These don't look like they'd be similar in weight to a nimbus cell. Nimbus cells are very tiny things in proportion to the frond. Much smaller than this. |
| QUOTE (Disgustedorite @ Apr 4 2023, 05:37 PM) |
| This is a little large to be using ionic wind. Do you have an example of anything, animal or machine, doing something similar at this size? |


| QUOTE (Disgustedorite @ Apr 4 2023, 05:39 PM) |
| My issues with the fungal core thing aside, the growth form is very strange. What's going on here? |
