

| QUOTE (Coolsteph @ Oct 13 2021, 03:20 PM) |
| You need to arrange the template so there isn't so much extra space between these: just press the enter key one time per sentence. I realize now that the Beta submission guide could be clearer. Try looking at submissions that already exist for formatting guidance. The scientific name should be in parenthesis just after the common name, and the common name should be just after the picture. It's not necessary to specify what the name means in the template, and generally isn't done, although you could specify what its name means in a trivia section of the description. You'll need to be more specific about its diet. There are a few "anything smaller than itself" exception submissions, but those are for genus-group submissions and microbe-level consumers, and even then it's typical to specify a few other genus groups or interactions with other species. For the diet of the larva, you'll have to specify exactly what it eats in the diet. The sentences are much too long. ", and who could blame them?" This too informal. It is okay to have the rare joke in Sagan 4 submissions, but it should be dry and formal-sounding. "who's oily" Whose oily. It's best to provide just one perspective on the submitted organism in the main image, although you can provide the other perspectives in supplemental images. I can provide more feedback later. |
| QUOTE (Disgustedorite @ Oct 16 2021, 04:17 AM) |
| I'm looking at this more closely now - why does it develop an endoskeleton, and why hydraulic muscles? Note, if you assumed earth anatomy for asterzoa, please try to avoid that--while they tend to resemble starfish, they do not have starfish characteristics. We also have a rule that the same shape endoskeleton cannot evolve twice, to prevent there from being 73629349726719610 independent vertebrate lineages. |
| QUOTE (Disgustedorite @ Oct 16 2021, 05:05 AM) |
| I think those would be hydrostatic muscles, not hydraulic (I used incorrect terminology in certain asterplents, which I have since fixed). |
| QUOTE (Disgustedorite @ Oct 16 2021, 05:05 AM) |
| The claws are made of keratin. How do they manage keratinous internal structures? |
| QUOTE (Disgustedorite @ Oct 16 2021, 05:05 AM) |
| I'm also not sure of the part where they gain more segments as they grow. How do they do that? In the ancestor, the number of segments was constant throughout life. |
| QUOTE (Disgustedorite @ Oct 16 2021, 05:05 AM) |
| Also, increasing the number of segments on the body would also increase the number of segments on the counter-arms) |
| QUOTE (Disgustedorite @ Oct 16 2021, 06:03 AM) |
| I believe the embryos divide into segments, rather than adding more; more like a vertebrate than an arthropod, I think, or perhaps the development of fingers might be a better comparison. |
| QUOTE (Disgustedorite @ Oct 16 2021, 06:03 AM) |
(There actually is a feature like this in most asterzoa; as their bilateral symmetry comes from modifying the original radial body plan, they are forced to have a radial developmental stage) |
| QUOTE (Disgustedorite @ Oct 16 2021, 06:03 AM) |
A single connected system of fluid used for movement using hydraulic pressure is a hydraulic system. Starfish have this. It's distinct from hydrostatic, where the volume doesn't change. Edit: I'm tired. We're having a discussion on what to do with terminology on the discord |